Analytical Skills-II
Unit 1: Time & Work + Pipes & Cisterns
From basic work formulas to complex pipe scenarios โ master every trick, shortcut, and pattern that placement exams test. Solve 50+ problems and guarantee 12-15 marks in TCS NQT, Infosys, and Wipro aptitude rounds.
โฑ๏ธ 6 hrs theory + 4 hrs practice | ๐ฏ TCS / Infosys / Wipro Aptitude | ๐ฐ Placement Essential
๐ 30 MCQs (Bloom's Mapped) | ๐งฎ 50+ Solved Problems | โก LCM Shortcut Method Included
Opening Hook โ Why This Chapter Can Change Your Placement Score
๐ฏ TCS NQT Asks 3โ4 Time & Work Problems Every Single Year
Infosys InfyTQ has pipes & cisterns in every round. Wipro NLTH dedicates 15% of its aptitude section to these two topics alone. Cognizant GenC tests work-efficiency problems that look scary but follow the same 8 formulas.
Master this chapter = 12โ15 marks guaranteed in placement exams. That's the difference between getting shortlisted and missing the cut. While other students panic over fractions and ratios, you'll solve these in 30โ60 seconds using the LCM method.
This isn't abstract math โ every IT company from TCS to Accenture tests these concepts because they mirror real project management: "If 5 developers can build a feature in 12 days, how many do you need to ship in 4 days?" That's a Time & Work problem disguised as a sprint planning question.
Learning Outcomes โ Bloom's Taxonomy Mapped (12 Outcomes)
| Bloom's Level | Learning Outcome |
|---|---|
| ๐ต Remember | Recall the basic formula: Work = Efficiency ร Time and express one day's work as 1/n |
| ๐ต Remember | List the 8 key formulas for Time & Work and Pipes & Cisterns problems |
| ๐ต Understand | Explain why the LCM method is faster and less error-prone than the fraction method |
| ๐ต Understand | Describe how inlet and outlet pipes affect the net filling rate of a cistern |
| ๐ข Apply | Solve standard Time & Work problems using both fraction and LCM methods within 60 seconds |
| ๐ข Apply | Calculate the time to fill or empty a tank with multiple pipes operating simultaneously |
| ๐ข Analyze | Compare efficiency of workers when given in ratio form (e.g., 2 men = 3 women = 5 children) |
| ๐ข Analyze | Determine the effect of a leak on pipe filling time and identify hidden variables in word problems |
| ๐ Evaluate | Assess which method (fraction vs LCM) is optimal for a given problem type in timed exam conditions |
| ๐ Evaluate | Judge whether a given solution to a pipes problem is correct and identify computational errors |
| ๐ Create | Design original Time & Work problems with real-world Indian contexts for peer practice |
| ๐ Create | Construct complex multi-step pipes and cisterns scenarios combining inlets, outlets, and partial filling |
Concept Explanation โ Time & Work + Pipes & Cisterns from Scratch
1. Basic Concept โ The Foundation Formula
Every Time & Work problem rests on one simple idea: if a person can complete a job in n days, then in one day they finish 1/n of the job. This is the single most important concept. Get this right, and everything else follows.
๐ Core Formula
If A can do a piece of work in n days:
A's 1 day's work = 1/n
Total Work = Efficiency ร Time
If A's efficiency = 1/n per day, then in d days, A completes d/n of the work.
Step 1: A's 1 day's work = 1/10
Step 2: In 3 days, A completes = 3 ร (1/10) = 3/10 of the work
Step 3: Remaining work = 1 โ 3/10 = 7/10
Answer: A does 1/10 of the work per day. In 3 days, 3/10 is complete.
P2. C completes a job in 25 days. How much is done in 5 days? (Answer: 5/25 = 1/5)
P3. D can paint a wall in 6 hours. What fraction is painted in 2 hours? (Answer: 2/6 = 1/3)
2. Work Done Together โ Combined Efficiency
When two or more people work together, their individual rates add up. If A does 1/a per day and B does 1/b per day, together they do (1/a + 1/b) per day.
๐ Combined Work Formula
If A takes a days and B takes b days alone:
Together: 1/a + 1/b = 1/T
Shortcut: T = (a ร b) / (a + b)
For three workers: 1/a + 1/b + 1/c = 1/T
Method 1 โ Fraction:
A's 1 day work = 1/12
B's 1 day work = 1/15
Together in 1 day = 1/12 + 1/15
LCM of 12 and 15 = 60
= 5/60 + 4/60 = 9/60 = 3/20
Time = 20/3 = 6โ days
Method 2 โ Direct Formula:
T = (12 ร 15) / (12 + 15) = 180 / 27 = 20/3 = 6โ days โ
P2. A = 20 days, B = 30 days. Together? (Answer: T = 600/50 = 12 days)
P3. A = 6 days, B = 12 days, C = 18 days. All together? (Answer: 1/6+1/12+1/18 = 6/36+3/36+2/36 = 11/36. T = 36/11 โ 3.27 days)
3. The LCM Method โ The Faster Way! โก
The fraction method works, but it's slow and error-prone under exam pressure. The LCM method converts everything to whole numbers โ no fractions, no mistakes, 2ร faster.
๐งฎ LCM Method โ Step by Step
Step 1: Take LCM of all the given days โ this becomes the Total Work (in units)
Step 2: Calculate each person's Efficiency = Total Work รท Their Days
Step 3: Add efficiencies for combined work
Step 4: Time = Total Work รท Combined Efficiency
Step 1: LCM(12, 15) = 60 โ Total Work = 60 units
Step 2: A's efficiency = 60/12 = 5 units/day
B's efficiency = 60/15 = 4 units/day
Step 3: Together = 5 + 4 = 9 units/day
Step 4: Time = 60/9 = 20/3 = 6โ days โ
Same answer as fractions โ but with zero fraction arithmetic! Just whole number division.
| Comparison | Fraction Method | LCM Method |
|---|---|---|
| Arithmetic | Fractions (error-prone) | Whole numbers (fast) |
| Speed | 60โ90 seconds | 30โ45 seconds |
| Best For | Simple 2-person problems | 3+ workers, complex scenarios |
| Exam Recommendation | Backup method | Primary method โ |
P2. A = 8 days, B = 12 days. Use LCM method. (LCM=24, A=3, B=2, Together=5, Time=24/5=4.8 days)
P3. A = 6, B = 8, C = 12. All together, LCM method. (LCM=24, A=4, B=3, C=2, Together=9, Time=24/9=8/3โ2.67 days)
4. Men, Women, and Children โ Efficiency Ratios
These problems give you equivalence like "2 men = 3 women = 5 children" and ask you to convert between them. The key is finding the efficiency ratio.
๐ Efficiency Ratio Conversion
If 2 men = 3 women = 5 children (in terms of work done):
1 man's work : 1 woman's work : 1 child's work
= 1/2 : 1/3 : 1/5
Multiply by LCM(2,3,5) = 30:
= 15 : 10 : 6
So 1 man = 1.5 women = 2.5 children in terms of efficiency.
Step 1: 2 men = 3 women โ 1 man = 3/2 women โ 1 woman = 2/3 man
Step 2: Convert 4 women to men: 4 ร (2/3) = 8/3 men
Step 3: Total = 3 + 8/3 = 9/3 + 8/3 = 17/3 men
Step 4: (17/3 men) ร 10 days = 170/3 man-days of total work
Step 5: 5 men ร D days = 170/3
Step 6: D = 170/(3ร5) = 170/15 = 11โ days โ
(1 woman = 3/5 man. 3 women = 9/5 men. Total = 2 + 9/5 = 19/5 men. Work = 19/5 ร 12 = 228/5 man-days. 4 men: 228/(5ร4) = 228/20 = 11.4 days)
P2. 4 men and 6 women finish in 8 days. 3 men and 7 women finish in 10 days. Find 10 women alone.
(Let 1 man = m, 1 woman = w. (4m+6w)ร8 = (3m+7w)ร10 โ 32m+48w=30m+70w โ 2m=22w โ m=11w. Total work = (4ร11w+6w)ร8 = 50wร8=400 woman-days. 10 women: 400/10 = 40 days)
5. Wages-Based Work Problems
When wages are mentioned, remember this rule: wages are distributed in proportion to the total work done. If everyone works the same number of days, wages are distributed in ratio of efficiency.
๐ Wages Formula
Wages โ Work Done = Efficiency ร Time
If A and B work together for the same duration:
Wage_A / Wage_B = Efficiency_A / Efficiency_B
If A can finish in a days and B in b days:
Efficiency ratio = 1/a : 1/b = b : a
Step 1: A's efficiency : B's efficiency = 1/10 : 1/15
Step 2: Multiply by LCM(10,15) = 30 โ 3 : 2
Step 3: A's share = (3/5) ร โน4,200 = โน2,520
Step 4: B's share = (2/5) ร โน4,200 = โน1,680 โ
Verification: โน2,520 + โน1,680 = โน4,200 โ
Step 1: Efficiency ratio = 1/6 : 1/8 : 1/12
Step 2: LCM(6,8,12) = 24 โ 4 : 3 : 2
Step 3: Total parts = 4 + 3 + 2 = 9
Step 4: C's share = (2/9) ร โน2,340 = โน520 โ
P2. P, Q, R finish in 5, 10, 15 days. Total wage โน6,600. R's share? (Ratio: 1/5:1/10:1/15 = 6:3:2. R = 2/11 ร 6600 = โน1,200)
6. Alternate Day Problems
In these problems, workers don't work together โ they alternate. A works on Day 1, B works on Day 2, A works on Day 3, and so on. The trick is to find work done in a 2-day cycle.
๐ Alternate Day Strategy
Step 1: Find work done by each person per day (use LCM method)
Step 2: Calculate work done in one complete cycle (2 days)
Step 3: Find number of complete cycles: Total Work รท Work per Cycle
Step 4: Check remaining work โ who works next? Calculate fractional day.
Step 1: LCM(12,15) = 60 units total work
A's efficiency = 60/12 = 5 units/day
B's efficiency = 60/15 = 4 units/day
Step 2: In 2-day cycle: 5 + 4 = 9 units
Step 3: Complete cycles = 60 รท 9 = 6 full cycles (12 days) = 54 units done
Remaining = 60 โ 54 = 6 units
Step 4: Day 13 (A's turn): A does 5 units โ Total = 59 units. Remaining = 1 unit.
Day 14 (B's turn): B needs to do 1 unit. B does 4 units/day โ Time = 1/4 day
Answer: 13 + 1/4 = 13ยผ days โ
(LCM=30, A=3, B=2. Cycle=5 units/2 days. 30/5=6 cycles=12 days exactly. Answer: 12 days)
P2. A = 8 days, B = 24 days. Alternate starting with B. When finished?
(LCM=24, A=3, B=1. Cycle=4/2 days. 24/4=6 cycles=12 days exactly. Answer: 12 days)
7. Pipes & Cisterns โ Inlet & Outlet Concept
Pipes & Cisterns is just Time & Work with a twist: inlets fill (positive work) and outlets/leaks empty (negative work). The math is identical โ only the direction changes.
๐ Pipes Formula
Inlet pipe fills tank in a hours โ Rate = +1/a per hour
Outlet pipe empties tank in b hours โ Rate = โ1/b per hour
Net Rate = Sum of all Inlet rates โ Sum of all Outlet rates
If Net Rate > 0 โ tank fills. If Net Rate < 0 โ tank empties.
Time to fill = 1 / Net Rate
Step 1: A's rate = +1/10 per hour (inlet)
B's rate = โ1/15 per hour (outlet)
Step 2: Net rate = 1/10 โ 1/15 = 3/30 โ 2/30 = 1/30 per hour
Step 3: Time = 1 รท (1/30) = 30 hours โ
P2. Two inlets fill in 6 hrs and 9 hrs. Together? (1/6+1/9=3/18+2/18=5/18. Time=18/5=3.6 hrs)
8. Part of Tank Filled โ Fractional Filling
๐ Fraction Filled Formula
After t hours, fraction of tank filled = t ร (net rate per hour)
Fraction remaining = 1 โ fraction filled
Fraction filled = 8/20 = 2/5 โ
Fraction remaining = 1 โ 2/5 = 3/5
Net rate = 1/20 โ 1/30 = 3/60 โ 2/60 = 1/60 per minute
Fraction filled in 12 min = 12 ร (1/60) = 12/60 = 1/5 โ
P2. Inlet: 10 hrs. Outlet: 25 hrs. Both open for 10 hrs. Fraction filled? (Net rate=1/10โ1/25=5/50โ2/50=3/50. In 10 hrs: 30/50=3/5)
9. Complex Pipe Scenarios โ Multiple Pipes, Leaks & Delays
Using LCM:
LCM(12, 16, 24) = 48 units (total capacity)
A = 48/12 = +4 units/hr (inlet)
B = 48/16 = +3 units/hr (inlet)
C = 48/24 = โ2 units/hr (outlet)
Net = 4 + 3 โ 2 = 5 units/hr
Time = 48/5 = 9 hrs 36 min (9.6 hrs) โ
Phase 1: A alone fills half the tank.
Time = 10/2 = 5 hours
Phase 2: A fills + B empties simultaneously for remaining half.
Net rate = 1/10 โ 1/12 = 6/60 โ 5/60 = 1/60 per hr
Time for half tank = (1/2) รท (1/60) = 30 hours
Total time = 5 + 30 = 35 hours โ
(LCM=24. A=+4, B=+3, C=โ2. Net=5. Time=24/5=4.8 hrs=4 hrs 48 min)
P2. A fills in 20 hrs. After 10 hrs (half full), B (empties in 30 hrs) opens. Total time?
(Phase 1: 10 hrs. Phase 2: Net=1/20โ1/30=1/60. Half=ยฝรท1/60=30 hrs. Total=40 hrs)
10. LCM Method for Pipes โ Convert to Units
The LCM method works identically for pipes. Take LCM of all pipe times as tank capacity, compute each pipe's rate in units per hour, then add (inlets) and subtract (outlets).
Step 1: LCM(15, 20, 30) = 60 units (tank capacity)
Step 2: A = 60/15 = +4 units/hr
B = 60/20 = +3 units/hr
C = 60/30 = โ2 units/hr
Step 3: Net = 4 + 3 โ 2 = 5 units/hr
Step 4: Time = 60/5 = 12 hours โ
(LCM=60. A=+6, B=+5, C=โ3. Net=8. Time=60/8=7.5 hrs)
P2. A fills in 24 hrs, B empties in 36 hrs. Both open. LCM method.
(LCM=72. A=+3, B=โ2. Net=1. Time=72/1=72 hrs)
๐ ALL 8 KEY FORMULAS โ Time & Work + Pipes & Cisterns
1. A's 1 day work = 1/n (if A finishes work in n days)
2. Two workers together: T = (a ร b) / (a + b)
3. LCM Method: Total Work = LCM(a, b); Efficiency = Total Work / Days
4. Three workers: 1/a + 1/b + 1/c = 1/T
5. Wages โ Efficiency (when all work for the same duration)
6. Inlet pipe rate = +1/a, Outlet pipe rate = โ1/b
7. Net rate (pipes) = Sum of Inlet rates โ Sum of Outlet rates
8. Time to fill/empty = Total Work / Net Rate
Learn by Doing โ 3-Tier Practice Structure
๐ข Tier 1 โ GUIDED: Basic Formula-Plug Problems (5 Problems)
Q1. A can do a piece of work in 20 days. Find A's 1 day's work.
Q2. A = 10 days, B = 15 days. How long will they take working together?
Q3. A pipe fills a tank in 24 hours. What fraction of the tank is filled in 6 hours?
Q4. A = 8 days, B = 12 days. Solve using LCM method.
Q5. A and B do a job in 10 and 15 days. Total wage โน4,200. Find A's share.
๐ก Tier 2 โ SEMI-GUIDED: TCS-Style Problems (10 Problems)
Time & Work (Q1โQ5)
Q1. A can do a work in 15 days. B can do it in 20 days. A works for 5 days and leaves. How many more days will B take to finish?
Hint: Find work done by A in 5 days, then remaining work for B.
Q2. A is twice as efficient as B. Together they finish a job in 12 days. How long does B take alone?
Hint: Let B's efficiency = x, A's = 2x.
Q3. 12 men can finish a work in 10 days. 15 women can finish it in 12 days. How many days will 6 men and 11 women take?
Hint: Find 1 man's and 1 woman's per-day work.
Q4. A and B together can complete a work in 8 days. B and C together in 12 days. A and C together in 16 days. How long will all three take together?
Hint: Add all three equations and divide by 2.
Q5. A can finish a work in 18 days and B in 27 days. They work together for 6 days. What fraction of work is left?
Hint: Find combined rate, multiply by 6.
Pipes & Cisterns (Q6โQ10)
Q6. Pipe A fills in 12 hrs, Pipe B fills in 18 hrs, Pipe C empties in 36 hrs. All open. Time to fill?
Hint: Use LCM method. Remember C is negative.
Q7. A tank has a leak which empties it in 8 hours. An inlet pipe fills at 6 litres/min. With both, tank fills in 12 hours. Find tank capacity.
Hint: Set up equation with fill and leak rates.
Q8. Two pipes A and B can fill a tank in 20 min and 30 min. Pipe C empties it in 15 min. If A and B are opened for 5 min, then all three for next 5 min, what fraction is filled?
Hint: Calculate two phases separately.
Q9. A pipe can fill a tank in 10 hours. Due to a leak at the bottom, it takes 12 hours. How long will the leak take to empty a full tank?
Hint: Leak rate = Difference of rates.
Q10. Pipe A fills in 15 hrs. Pipe B fills in 20 hrs. They alternate every hour starting with A. How long to fill?
Hint: This is alternate day work applied to pipes.
๐ด Tier 3 โ OPEN CHALLENGE: Advanced Mixed Problems (5 Problems)
Q1. A and B can do a piece of work in 45 and 40 days. They begin together. After some days, A leaves and B finishes the remaining work in 23 days. After how many days did A leave?
Q2. 10 men can complete a work in 15 days. 15 women can complete the same work in 12 days. If 8 men and 5 women work together, and after 6 days 5 men leave, how many more days will the remaining team take?
Q3. Two pipes A and B fill a tank in 12 and 16 minutes. A third pipe C empties 7 litres/min. All three together fill the tank in 24 minutes. Find the tank's capacity.
Q4. A can do a work in 6 days, B in 8 days, C in 12 days. A works on Day 1, B on Day 2, C on Day 3, then A on Day 4, and so on. When is the work completed?
Q5. A cistern is filled by pipes A and B in 10 and 12 hours. It's emptied by pipe C in 20 hours. If the cistern is half full and all pipes are opened, in how much time will the cistern be full?
Problem Set โ Comprehensive Practice
Formula-Based Problems (5)
๐ Direct Application of Formulas
Q1. A can do 1/5 of a work in 3 days. How many days to complete the full work?
Solution: If 1/5 work = 3 days, then full work = 3 ร 5 = 15 days โ
Q2. A and B together finish a job in 8 days. A alone takes 12 days. How long does B take alone?
Solution: 1/A + 1/B = 1/8. Since A=12: 1/12 + 1/B = 1/8 โ 1/B = 1/8 โ 1/12 = 3/24 โ 2/24 = 1/24. B = 24 days โ
Q3. Pipe A fills in 6 hrs, Pipe B fills in 8 hrs. Together?
Solution: T = (6ร8)/(6+8) = 48/14 = 24/7 hours โ 3 hrs 26 min โ
Q4. 10 men finish a work in 12 days. How many men needed to finish in 8 days?
Solution: Man-days = 10ร12 = 120. For 8 days: 120/8 = 15 men โ
Q5. A is 3 times as efficient as B. Together they finish in 9 days. A alone?
Solution: Let B's rate = x, A's rate = 3x. Together = 4x = 1/9. So x = 1/36.
A's rate = 3x = 3/36 = 1/12. A alone = 12 days โ
Word Problems (8)
๐ Real-World Scenarios
Q1. Ravi can build a wall in 10 days. Suresh can do it in 15 days. They work together for 3 days, then Ravi leaves. How many more days will Suresh take to finish?
Solution:
Combined rate = 1/10 + 1/15 = 3/30 + 2/30 = 5/30 = 1/6 per day
Work in 3 days = 3 ร 1/6 = 1/2
Remaining = 1 โ 1/2 = 1/2
Suresh's rate = 1/15. Time = (1/2) รท (1/15) = 15/2 = 7.5 days โ
Q2. A tap fills a cistern in 8 hours. After half the tank is filled, 3 more identical taps are opened. How long to fill completely?
Solution:
Half filled by 1 tap: 8/2 = 4 hours
Now 4 taps fill remaining half: combined rate = 4/8 = 1/2 per hr
Time for half = (1/2) รท (1/2) = 1 hour
Total = 4 + 1 = 5 hours โ
Q3. A contractor hired 150 workers to complete a project in 60 days. After 20 days, he realised only 1/4 of the work was done. How many additional workers must he hire to complete on time?
Solution:
Total work = 150 ร 60 = 9000 worker-days
Done in 20 days = 150 ร 20 = 3000 worker-days (which is 1/3 of what he expected but 1/4 of actual)
Remaining work = 3/4 of total. Remaining days = 40.
Workers needed = (3/4 ร 9000 ร 60/9000) ... Let's recalculate:
Actual total work: If 150 workers ร 20 days = 1/4 work, then total = 150 ร 20 ร 4 = 12000 worker-days
Remaining = 3/4 ร 12000 = 9000 worker-days in 40 days
Workers needed = 9000/40 = 225
Additional workers = 225 โ 150 = 75 workers โ
Q4. 20 women can complete a work in 14 days. 10 men can complete the same work in 14 days. How many days will 5 men and 10 women take?
Solution:
Total work = 20 ร 14 = 280 woman-days = 10 ร 14 = 140 man-days
1 man = 280/140 = 2 women (in efficiency)
5 men + 10 women = 5ร2 + 10 = 20 women equivalent
Time = 280/20 = 14 days โ
Q5. A pipe can fill a pool in 12 hours. Due to a crack, water leaks out. The pool is filled in 20 hours instead. If the pool is full and the filling pipe is closed, how long to empty through the crack?
Solution:
Pipe rate = 1/12. Net rate = 1/20.
Leak rate = 1/12 โ 1/20 = 5/60 โ 3/60 = 2/60 = 1/30
Leak empties in 30 hours โ
Q6. A, B, and C can do a piece of work in 10, 12, and 15 days respectively. They all start together. After 2 days, A leaves. After 2 more days, B also leaves. How many more days will C take to finish?
Solution:
LCM(10,12,15) = 60 units. A=6, B=5, C=4.
Days 1-2: All three = (6+5+4)ร2 = 30 units
Days 3-4: B+C = (5+4)ร2 = 18 units
Total done = 48 units. Remaining = 12 units.
C alone: 12/4 = 3 more days โ
Q7. 3 pipes A, B, C can fill a tank in 6, 8 and 12 hours respectively. The tank is 1/4 full. Pipe C is opened first. After 2 hours, A and B are also opened. How much more time to fill?
Solution:
LCM(6,8,12) = 24 units. A=4, B=3, C=2.
Tank is 1/4 full โ 6 units done. Remaining = 18 units.
C alone for 2 hrs: 2ร2 = 4 units. Remaining = 14 units.
All three: 4+3+2 = 9 units/hr. Time = 14/9 โ 1.56 hrs โ 1 hr 33 min after A,B open โ
Q8. X can do a work in 40 days. He starts the work. After 8 days, Y joins him. Together they complete the remaining work in 16 days. How long would Y take alone?
Solution:
X's rate = 1/40. Work X did in 8 days = 8/40 = 1/5. Remaining = 4/5.
X + Y in 16 days = 4/5 โ (1/40 + 1/Y) ร 16 = 4/5
1/40 + 1/Y = 4/80 = 1/20
1/Y = 1/20 โ 1/40 = 2/40 โ 1/40 = 1/40
Y = 40 days โ
TCS Previous Year Style (3)
๐ข TCS NQT / Infosys Style
Q1. [TCS Style] A can complete a task in 20 days. B is 25% more efficient than A. How many days does B take?
Solution:
A's efficiency = 1/20. B is 25% more efficient โ B's efficiency = 1.25 ร (1/20) = 1.25/20 = 1/16
B takes 16 days โ
Q2. [TCS Style] If 6 men and 8 women can complete a work in 10 days while 26 men and 48 women can do it in 2 days, find the time taken by 15 men and 20 women.
Solution:
(6m + 8w) ร 10 = (26m + 48w) ร 2
60m + 80w = 52m + 96w
8m = 16w โ 1m = 2w
Total work = (6ร2 + 8) ร 10 = 20w ร 10 = 200 woman-days
15m + 20w = 15ร2 + 20 = 50w
Time = 200/50 = 4 days โ
Q3. [TCS Style] Two pipes can fill a tank in 15 and 20 minutes. Both are opened. After 4 minutes, the first pipe is closed. How much more time to fill?
Solution:
LCM(15,20) = 60. A=4, B=3.
In 4 min: (4+3)ร4 = 28 units. Remaining = 32 units.
B alone: 32/3 = 10โ
minutes more โ
Interview Questions (3)
๐ค Interview / HR Round
Q1. "If you had 5 developers to build a feature in 10 days, and 2 developers leave after 4 days, how would you plan?"
Model Answer: Total work = 5 ร 10 = 50 person-days. In 4 days with 5 devs = 20 done. Remaining = 30 person-days with 3 devs. Time = 30/3 = 10 more days. I'd inform stakeholders of the 4-day delay early and prioritise critical features. This shows I understand resource planning using Time & Work logic.
Q2. "Explain what happens to project timelines when you add more people to a late project."
Model Answer: Brooks's Law: "Adding people to a late project makes it later." New members need onboarding time (learning curve), increasing coordination overhead. In Time & Work terms, their effective efficiency is initially very low, and the training burden reduces existing team efficiency. After the learning phase, they contribute positively โ but the net effect can be negative short-term.
Q3. "How is the concept of 'efficiency' used in software sprint planning?"
Model Answer: In Agile, each developer has a "velocity" (story points per sprint) โ this is exactly their efficiency in Time & Work terms. Sprint capacity = sum of all velocities (combined rate). The PM assigns stories such that total story points โค sprint capacity. This is the LCM method in practice: convert everything to the same unit (story points) and calculate total capacity.
MCQ Assessment Bank โ 30 Questions (Bloom's Mapped)
Remember / Recall (Q1โQ5)
If A can complete a work in 12 days, A's one day's work is:
- 1/6
- 1/12
- 12
- 1/24
The formula for time taken by A and B working together is:
- T = a + b
- T = a โ b
- T = (a ร b) / (a + b)
- T = (a + b) / (a ร b)
An outlet pipe is one that:
- Fills the tank
- Empties the tank
- Both fills and empties
- Has no effect on the tank
In the LCM method, what does the LCM of the given days represent?
- The number of workers
- The total work in units
- The efficiency of each worker
- The time to complete work
If wages are distributed based on work done, and all workers work the same duration, wages are proportional to:
- Number of days
- Efficiency
- Age of workers
- Experience
Understand / Explain (Q6โQ10)
Why is the LCM method considered faster than the fraction method for Time & Work problems?
- It uses smaller numbers
- It converts fractions to whole number units, eliminating fraction arithmetic
- It requires fewer steps
- It only works for 2 workers
When an inlet pipe (rate 1/a) and outlet pipe (rate 1/b) are both open, with a < b, the tank:
- Overflows
- Fills up, because inlet rate exceeds outlet rate
- Empties, because outlet is faster
- Stays at the same level
If 2 men = 3 women in work efficiency, which statement is correct?
- 1 man is less efficient than 1 woman
- 1 man is 1.5 times as efficient as 1 woman
- 1 man is 2/3 as efficient as 1 woman
- Men and women are equally efficient
In alternate day problems, why is it important to check if work finishes "mid-cycle"?
- Because workers might take a break
- Because the remaining work after full cycles might not require a complete day from the next worker
- Because alternate days are holidays
- Because the formula changes mid-cycle
Why can't you simply add the number of days when two people work together?
- Because days and rates are inversely related
- Because one person might be lazy
- Because the formula is always subtraction
- Because the work gets harder over time
Apply / Solve โ Time & Work (Q11โQ15)
A does a work in 10 days, B in 15 days. Working together, they will finish in:
- 5 days
- 6 days
- 12.5 days
- 25 days
A can do a work in 16 days. B is 60% more efficient than A. B alone will finish in:
- 8 days
- 10 days
- 12 days
- 6 days
8 men can finish a work in 12 days. 6 men started the work. After 8 days, 2 more men joined. Total days to complete?
- 14 days
- 13 days
- 12 days
- 11 days
A and B can complete a work in 12 days. B and C in 15 days. C and A in 20 days. All three together will complete in:
- 10 days
- 120/13 days
- 8 days
- 15 days
A is thrice as efficient as B. A takes 20 days less than B. How many days does B take alone?
- 30 days
- 25 days
- 20 days
- 15 days
Apply / Solve โ Pipes & Cisterns (Q16โQ20)
Pipe A fills a tank in 10 hrs, Pipe B fills in 15 hrs. Both open. Time to fill?
- 5 hrs
- 6 hrs
- 12 hrs
- 25 hrs
A pipe fills a tank in 12 hours. A leak empties it in 20 hours. Both active โ time to fill?
- 30 hrs
- 24 hrs
- 15 hrs
- 8 hrs
Three pipes A(+8hrs), B(+12hrs), C(โ24hrs). All open. Time to fill?
- 8 hrs
- 12 hrs
- 24/5 hrs
- 6 hrs
A cistern fills in 10 hrs. Due to a leak, it fills in 12 hrs. The leak alone empties in:
- 30 hrs
- 40 hrs
- 60 hrs
- 120 hrs
Pipe A fills in 6 hrs. After half the tank is full, Pipe B (empties in 8 hrs) is opened. Total time?
- 15 hrs
- 27 hrs
- 30 hrs
- 3 hrs
Analyze / Compare (Q21โQ25)
A takes 12 days, B takes 18 days. They work together for 4 days, then A leaves. How many more days for B to finish?
- 10 days
- 12 days
- 6 days
- 5 days
A is 50% more efficient than B. A finishes a work in 12 days. Together they finish in:
- 36/5 days
- 7.5 days
- 8 days
- 60/7 days
Two pipes fill in 10 and 12 hrs. A drain pipe is also open. All three together fill in 15 hrs. The drain pipe alone empties in:
- 8 hrs
- 10 hrs
- 12 hrs
- 20 hrs
A, B, C can finish a work individually in 10, 15, and 30 days. All start together. C is removed after 2 days. Remaining time for A and B?
- 4 days
- 3 days
- 5 days
- 2 days
20 men can finish a work in 30 days. After how many days should 5 men leave so that work finishes on time in 35 days total (starting with 20)?
- 20 days
- 15 days
- 10 days
- 25 days
Evaluate / Create (Q26โQ30)
A student solved: "A=10 days, B=20 days, together = 30 days." What error did they make?
- They subtracted instead of adding
- They added the days instead of adding the rates
- They used the wrong formula
- The answer is actually correct
Is it possible for two pipes working together to take LONGER than either pipe alone?
- Yes, always
- No, never
- Only if one is an outlet pipe and its rate exceeds the inlet
- Only with three or more pipes
A student claims: "If A is twice as efficient as B, A takes twice as many days." Is this correct?
- Yes, more efficient means more days
- No, more efficient means fewer days โ A takes half the days
- It depends on the type of work
- Efficiency and days are unrelated
Design a problem where 3 workers together finish in exactly 4 days. If Worker A takes 12 days and Worker B takes 8 days, what must Worker C take?
- 24 days
- 18 days
- 6 days
- 20 days
If you were designing a placement exam, which Time & Work problem type would best test analytical thinking?
- Simple formula plug (A=10, B=15, together?)
- Alternate day with mid-cycle finish
- Direct rate calculation
- One-step man-days calculation
Short Answer Questions (8)
๐ Model Answers (4โ5 lines each)
Q1. What is the basic principle behind Time & Work problems?
The basic principle is that if a person can complete a piece of work in 'n' days, their one day's work is 1/n of the total work. Work, Efficiency, and Time are related by the formula: Work = Efficiency ร Time. When multiple people work together, their individual rates (efficiencies) are added to get the combined rate. The total time is then found by dividing total work by the combined rate.
Q2. Explain the LCM method with a simple example.
The LCM method avoids fractions by assuming total work = LCM of given days. For example, if A takes 10 days and B takes 15 days: LCM(10,15) = 30 units of total work. A's efficiency = 30/10 = 3 units/day. B's efficiency = 30/15 = 2 units/day. Together = 5 units/day. Time = 30/5 = 6 days. This gives the same answer as fractions but uses only whole numbers, making it faster and less error-prone in exams.
Q3. How do you handle alternate day work problems?
In alternate day problems, calculate the work done in one complete cycle (usually 2 days โ one day per worker). Find the number of complete cycles by dividing total work by work-per-cycle. After complete cycles, track remaining work carefully: identify who works next, and if their one-day output exceeds the remaining work, calculate the fractional day needed. The key pitfall is forgetting to check mid-cycle completion.
Q4. What is the relationship between wages and efficiency?
Wages are distributed in proportion to the work done by each person. Work Done = Efficiency ร Time worked. When all workers work for the same duration, wages are simply proportional to their efficiency. For example, if A's efficiency is 5 units/day and B's is 3 units/day, and they both work the same number of days, wages split in 5:3 ratio. If they work different durations, you must calculate actual work done by each.
Q5. Explain the concept of inlet and outlet pipes.
Inlet pipes fill a tank โ their rate is positive (+1/a per hour if they fill alone in 'a' hours). Outlet pipes or leaks empty the tank โ their rate is negative (โ1/b per hour). When multiple pipes are open simultaneously, the net rate = sum of all inlet rates minus sum of all outlet rates. If net rate is positive, the tank fills; if negative, it empties. Time to fill/empty = Total capacity รท |Net rate|.
Q6. How do you convert "2 men = 3 women" into efficiency ratios?
"2 men = 3 women" means 2 men do the same work as 3 women in the same time. So 1 man = 3/2 women = 1.5 women in efficiency. To express as a ratio: Man's efficiency : Woman's efficiency = 1/2 : 1/3. Multiplying by LCM(2,3) = 6 gives 3:2. This means a man is 1.5ร as efficient as a woman. Use this ratio to convert between man-days and woman-days.
Q7. What happens when a pipe fills and a leak empties simultaneously?
The net effect depends on which rate is larger. If the filling pipe (rate 1/a) is faster than the leak (rate 1/b), i.e., a < b, the tank slowly fills at net rate (1/a โ 1/b). The time to fill increases compared to the pipe alone. For example, if a pipe fills in 10 hrs and leak empties in 15 hrs, net rate = 1/10 โ 1/15 = 1/30, and the tank fills in 30 hrs instead of 10 hrs.
Q8. Why is the LCM method preferred in competitive exams?
Competitive exams like TCS NQT give 30-40 seconds per question. The LCM method eliminates fraction arithmetic entirely, using only multiplication and division of small whole numbers. It reduces calculation time by 50% and virtually eliminates computational errors from adding/subtracting fractions with different denominators. For problems with 3+ workers or complex scenarios, the speed advantage is even greater. This is why coaching institutes universally teach LCM method as the primary technique.
Long Answer Questions (3)
๐ LA1: Compare Fraction Method vs LCM Method
Question: Compare and contrast the Fraction Method and LCM Method for solving Time & Work problems. Which is better for competitive exams and why? Illustrate with a problem involving three workers.
Model Answer:
The Fraction Method is the traditional approach where each worker's per-day output is expressed as a fraction (1/n). To find the combined time, we add fractions: 1/a + 1/b + 1/c = 1/T. This requires finding a common denominator, adding numerators, and then inverting. While mathematically straightforward, it involves multiple fraction operations that are time-consuming and error-prone under exam pressure.
The LCM Method takes a different approach: assume the total work equals the LCM of all given days. Each worker's efficiency becomes a whole number (Total Work รท Days). Combined efficiency is a simple addition. Time = Total Work รท Combined Efficiency. The entire calculation uses whole numbers only.
Example: A = 6 days, B = 8 days, C = 12 days. Find time together.
Fraction Method: 1/6 + 1/8 + 1/12. LCM(6,8,12) = 24. = 4/24 + 3/24 + 2/24 = 9/24 = 3/8. T = 8/3 โ 2.67 days. (Required 4 fraction operations)
LCM Method: LCM = 24 units. A = 4, B = 3, C = 2. Total = 9. Time = 24/9 = 8/3 โ 2.67 days. (Only 3 divisions and 1 addition)
The LCM method is superior for competitive exams because: (1) it's 40-50% faster, (2) whole number arithmetic eliminates fraction errors, (3) it scales better for 3+ worker problems, and (4) it works identically for Pipes & Cisterns. The fraction method is useful as a conceptual foundation and for verification, but the LCM method should be the primary technique for timed exams.
๐ LA2: Complex Pipes & Cisterns Problem
Question: Explain Pipes & Cisterns problems with a complex example involving 3 pipes (2 inlet, 1 outlet). Show the complete solution using both methods.
Model Answer:
Pipes & Cisterns problems are a variant of Time & Work where inlet pipes do "positive work" (fill) and outlet pipes do "negative work" (empty). The net rate determines whether the tank fills or empties.
Problem: Pipe A fills a tank in 15 hours. Pipe B fills it in 20 hours. Pipe C empties it in 30 hours. All pipes are opened simultaneously. How long will it take to fill the tank?
Fraction Method:
A's rate = +1/15 (fills), B's rate = +1/20 (fills), C's rate = โ1/30 (empties)
Net rate = 1/15 + 1/20 โ 1/30
LCM(15,20,30) = 60
= 4/60 + 3/60 โ 2/60 = 5/60 = 1/12
Time = 12 hours
LCM Method:
LCM(15,20,30) = 60 units (tank capacity)
A = 60/15 = +4 units/hr (inlet)
B = 60/20 = +3 units/hr (inlet)
C = 60/30 = โ2 units/hr (outlet)
Net = 4 + 3 โ 2 = 5 units/hr
Time = 60/5 = 12 hours โ
Both methods give the same answer, but the LCM method is cleaner. The critical concept is that outlet rates must be subtracted. A common extension asks: "If pipe C is opened 2 hours after A and B, find total time." Here, you'd solve in phases: Phase 1 (A+B for 2 hrs), then Phase 2 (all three for remaining work). Phase-based problems are extremely common in TCS and Infosys and require careful tracking of work done in each phase.
๐ LA3: Time & Work in Real-World Project Management
Question: Discuss how Time & Work concepts apply to real-world project management. Give examples from the IT industry.
Model Answer:
Time & Work mathematics directly underpins modern project management in the IT industry. The core formula โ Work = Efficiency ร Time โ is used daily in sprint planning, resource allocation, and project estimation.
Sprint Planning (Agile): In Scrum methodology, each developer has a "velocity" measured in story points per sprint. This is their efficiency. The team's combined velocity = sum of individual velocities โ exactly the LCM method applied to software. If Dev A can do 15 points/sprint and Dev B can do 10 points/sprint, their team capacity is 25 points/sprint.
Resource Allocation: When a TCS project manager needs to deliver a module in 30 days with 5 developers, total work = 150 person-days. If 2 developers leave mid-project (like "A leaves after 10 days"), the PM must recalculate: remaining work รท remaining team = new deadline. This is a direct Time & Work problem.
Brooks's Law: "Adding people to a late project makes it later." This is the real-world exception to the simple model. New joiners have negative initial efficiency (training overhead), similar to an outlet pipe reducing net filling rate. Over time, they become productive (efficiency turns positive). Good PMs account for this ramp-up period in their calculations.
Parallel vs Sequential: Just as pipes working together fill faster than sequentially, parallel task execution in projects reduces total time. However, some tasks have dependencies (can't test before coding), similar to how we can't add rates for sequential work. Understanding independence vs dependency is key to both Time & Work problems and project management.
Companies like Infosys, Wipro, and TCS specifically test these concepts in aptitude rounds because they directly translate to project management skills that every engineer needs.
Industry Spotlight โ Success Story
๐จโ๐ผ Ravi Sharma, 23 โ Placed at TCS Digital (โน7 LPA)
Background: BCA from Lucknow University. Struggled with aptitude initially โ scored only 8/30 in his first TCS NQT mock test. Time & Work was his weakest topic. He spent 3 months practicing 500+ problems from IndiaBix, PrepInsta, and EduArtha.
The Turning Point: "The LCM method changed everything for me. Before that, I was drowning in fractions โ getting the wrong LCM, messing up additions, running out of time. Once I switched to the LCM method, I could solve any Time & Work problem in 30โ60 seconds. My accuracy went from 40% to 95%."
Result: Scored 28/30 in the TCS NQT aptitude section. Got selected for TCS Digital (higher pay band) with โน7 LPA package. Now mentors juniors at his college.
His Advice: "Don't just read formulas โ solve 50 problems minimum. After 50, your brain starts recognizing patterns automatically. Time & Work and Pipes & Cisterns together are worth 15+ marks. Master these two, and you've already cleared the aptitude cut-off."
| Detail | Info |
|---|---|
| Preparation Resources | IndiaBix, PrepInsta, EduArtha, RS Aggarwal |
| Practice Volume | 500+ problems over 3 months |
| Mock Test Improvement | 8/30 โ 28/30 |
| Key Technique | LCM Method for all Time & Work problems |
| Package | TCS Digital โ โน7 LPA |
| Companies that test this | TCS, Infosys, Wipro, Cognizant, Accenture, HCL, Capgemini |
Earn With It โ Aptitude Tutoring Roadmap
๐ฐ Aptitude Tutoring โ โน300โ800/hr
After mastering this chapter, you can start earning by teaching aptitude to juniors, coaching centre students, and placement aspirants. You don't need to be a math genius โ you just need to be one chapter ahead of your students.
Earning Paths:
โข Offline tutoring at college: โน300โ500/hr โ teach 2-3 juniors preparing for TCS/Infosys
โข Online doubt solving (Chegg/Doubtnut): โน150โ300 per question solved
โข YouTube aptitude channel: โน5,000โ20,000/month with 1000+ subscribers
โข WhatsApp group coaching: โน500โ1,000/month per student (group of 10-20)
โข Unacademy Educator: โน500โ1,000/hr for live classes
| Platform | Best For | Typical Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Chegg | Solving individual doubts | โน150โ300/question |
| Doubtnut | Video solutions to problems | โน400โ600/hr |
| Unacademy | Live aptitude classes | โน500โ1,000/hr |
| YouTube | Passive income, brand building | โน5,000โ20,000/month (1000+ subs) |
| College Tutoring | Direct 1-on-1 or small group | โน300โ500/hr |
โฑ๏ธ Time to First Earning: 1โ2 weeks (once you've solved 50+ problems and feel confident)
Chapter Summary & Formula Sheet
๐ Key Takeaways
- Foundation: If A finishes in n days โ A's 1 day work = 1/n. This is the building block for everything.
- Combined Work: Add rates, not days. T = (aรb)/(a+b) for two workers.
- LCM Method: The fastest approach โ convert to total work units, calculate efficiency as whole numbers, add/subtract, and divide. No fractions needed.
- Men-Women-Children: Convert all to a common unit using the given equivalence ratio.
- Wages: Distributed in proportion to work done. Same duration โ wages โ efficiency.
- Alternate Days: Find work per 2-day cycle. Count complete cycles. Check remaining work carefully for mid-cycle finish.
- Pipes & Cisterns: Inlets = positive rate. Outlets/Leaks = negative rate. Net rate determines filling/emptying.
- Phase Problems: When conditions change mid-problem (someone leaves, pipe opens), solve in phases.
- Exam Strategy: Use LCM method as primary. Verify with fraction method if time permits. Practice 50+ problems for pattern recognition.
๐ MASTER FORMULA SHEET โ Print & Keep!
TIME & WORK:
1. A's 1 day work = 1/n (if A finishes in n days)
2. Two workers together: T = (a ร b) / (a + b)
3. Three workers: 1/a + 1/b + 1/c = 1/T
4. LCM Method: Total Work = LCM(a, b, ...); Efficiency = Total / Days
5. Efficiency ratio when 'm men = n women': 1 man = n/m women
6. Wages โ Efficiency ร Time (if same time โ Wages โ Efficiency)
7. If A is x% more efficient than B: A's days = B's days ร 100/(100+x)
PIPES & CISTERNS:
8. Inlet rate = +1/a per hour; Outlet rate = โ1/b per hour
9. Net rate = ฮฃ(Inlet rates) โ ฮฃ(Outlet rates)
10. Time to fill/empty = 1 / |Net Rate| or Total Units / Net Efficiency
11. Leak detection: Leak rate = (Rate without leak) โ (Rate with leak)
12. Fraction filled in t hours = t ร Net Rate
Earning Checkpoint โ Self-Assessment
| Skill | Method/Tool | Portfolio Evidence | Earning-Ready? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic Time & Work | Pen & Paper, Fraction Method | Solved 20+ basic problems | โ Can tutor juniors |
| LCM Method | Mental Math / Quick Calculation | Speed solving under 60 seconds | โ Competitive exam ready |
| Pipes & Cisterns | LCM Method for Pipes | Solved 15+ pipe problems | โ TCS/Infosys ready |
| Alternate Day / Wages | Advanced LCM techniques | Complex scenario solving | โ Interview ready |
| Men-Women-Children | Ratio conversion | Mixed problems solved | โ Can handle any variation |
| Aptitude Tutoring | Teaching LCM method | Helped 3+ peers | โ โน300โ500/hr ready |
Unit Complete!
โ Unit 1 complete. MCQs: 30. Problems Solved: 50+. Ready for Unit 2!
You've mastered Time & Work and Pipes & Cisterns โ the two highest-scoring topics in placement aptitude exams. With the LCM method in your toolkit, you can solve any problem in 30โ60 seconds.
[QR: Link to EduArtha video tutorial โ Time & Work + Pipes & Cisterns]